As we wrestle with the challenges of Covid-19 the weaknesses
inherent in our federation are being clearly seen. These weaknesses have been
present since 'federation' in 1901 but have been amplified by various legislative,
legal and administrative actions. Our state and federal politicians are not willing
or able to resolve these issues.
A Constitutional Council of esteemed Australians, not
involved in daily political life, should be permanently established to develop
referendum proposals to overcome the lack of clarity in federal, state and
local government responsibilities and other changes needed so that our constitution
reflects the requirements of contemporary Australia.
Getting the right balance between local, state and federal
responsibilities for revenue and services would make Australia a stronger and more cohesive nation.
“Rather than have an all-powerful unitary government, federations offer
the advantage of several governments operating closer to their constituents. By
rights, accountability is enhanced and sub-national governments can learn from
each other.” ...“The empirical evidence
from around the world is also strongly supportive of federations. Federated countries
consistently have outperformed unitary states in terms of the key economic
parameters, such as gross domestic product growth, unemployment and the like.”Judith Sloan – The Australian 20/7/21
“…current rules for holding a referendum are archaic and ill-suited
to modern times. Fortunately, parliament has begun work on this through a new
inquiry by the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Social Policy and
Legal Affairs.” The Australian 19/7/21 :
George Williams - Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Professor of Law at the University
of New South Wales The sad truth is that our politicians are not trusted enough to be in
charge of an issue as important as Constitutional Reform. Our country needs a
Constitutional Council outside the political sphere to undertake such important
reform now and into the future.
"The closely watched Edelman Trust Barometer’s half-year update reveals a
rapid decline in trust in government, business and media...The level of trust in government in Australia (52 per cent) puts it
below the average of 14 global counterparts (56 per cent), but still above the
US, which sits at 48 points."The Australian 19/7/21
“Freedom House, a non-partisan organisation dedicated to promoting
freedom and democracy, reports that freedom across the globe has declined for
15 straight years.""Across a swath of central Europe and central Asia in particular, a total
of 18 countries suffered declines in democratic trends last year, while only
six in those regions saw improvement.""Democracy is messy, but in an authoritarian system the problem is the
lack of messiness. Cults of personality develop, opposing voices with
potentially good ideas are squelched, healthy debates and innovative thoughts
are blocked.”Gerald F. Seib The Wall
Street Journal (Reprinted The Australian - 14/7/21)
“When Barbara Holland, professor of mathematics at
the University of Tasmania, was making the decision to have an AZ jab now
rather than wait for Pfizer, she deployed her number-crunching prowess.
…
Using UK data, she calculated that “I’d have about
a 1/60,000 chance of dying of Covid-19 in the next 90 days; balance that
against a 1/900,000 chance of a fatal blood clot, working off a 1/30,000 chance
of a clot x 1/30 chance of it being fatal.”
Jane Nicholls The Australian 6/7/21